Exploring Visual Identification of Raptor Species Through Gesture and Observation
Introduction: Why Study Birds in Animation?
Gesture drawing is a foundational skill in animation. It is the ability to capture motion and form within seconds of observation while being extremely economical with line. However, while observing these creatures in person, I noticed that identifying individual raptor species quickly was quite difficult. This presented a problem. Without proper identification, recording species-specific gestural studies, flight mechanics and behaviour was virtually impossible.
Although there are numerous field guides and bird identification resources available, these are designed primarily for birdwatchers and ornithologists. Consequently, the emphasis is generally on taxonomy, plumage and detailed descriptions. What artists and animators specifically need are identifiable visual cues that can be quickly recognised and translated into drawings.
This led me to explore an interesting question:
How can a visual framework support artists and animators in identifying the most effective visual characteristics that help distinguish raptor species, both perched and in flight?
The focus of this research is to develop a simplified artistic framework that helps identify the most effective visual characteristics for distinguishing raptor species. Presented as a visual reference resource, this approach aims to help artists and animators rapidly identify and record species-specific form, movement and behaviour for animated productions and artistic expression.
For this initial investigation, I decided to focus on the Peregrine Falcon as a starting point for developing and testing this approach.
What Can Artists Learn?
Observational drawing has long been considered a foundational cornerstone of animation training. It allows artists to develop a deeper understanding of movement, anatomy and emotion, which can then be captured within an animated performance.
Gesture exercises, such as running-line gestures, allow artists to capture motion, structure and weight while remaining economical with line. This is an essential skill in both traditional and digital animation (Williams, 2001). Animation artists have required guidance in this field for decades, leading veteran Disney artists to produce instructional volumes exploring the craft and nuances of gesture drawing (Hahn & Stanchfield, 2023).
As animation has evolved and stories have expanded in scope, the observation and study of real-world subjects in nature have become increasingly important in creating believable movement for artistic interpretation.
Birds, however, present a particularly complex challenge. Their anatomy is intricately connected to rapid and often unpredictable movement. Research into avian biomechanics has demonstrated that differences in wing proportions and anatomy among species can result in significant variations in flight behaviour and capabilities (Wang et al., 2011).
These characteristics can be studied and interpreted by artists and animators, but only if the observer can first differentiate between species in the field.
There are several excellent illustrated field guides covering this subject, including Raptors of the World (Ferguson-Lees & Christie, 2005) and Field Guide to the Birds of the United Arab Emirates (Aspinall & Porter, 2020). These resources cover plumage, proportions, habitat and flight characteristics, illustrating species in extensive detail. However, they are primarily designed for ornithological identification and birdwatching rather than the rapid visual analysis required by artists working from direct observation.
Recent studies and resources on observational drawing and nature journaling suggest that sketching is not simply a method of recording information, but also a tool that encourages closer observation. The Cornell Lab of Ornithology, for example, advocates gesture drawing as a method of studying birds in the field (Cornell Lab of Ornithology, 2022).
It is widely accepted that humans recognise subjects through simplified silhouettes, shapes and patterns. These principles have been used extensively in animation and visual art (Myers & Arnheim, 1956), but they have rarely been adapted into a dedicated visual framework for wildlife identification.
I believe that the visual analysis skills developed by animation artists could provide value beyond artistic production. By simplifying complex scientific studies into accessible visual frameworks, artists could potentially support researchers, birdwatchers and educators in communicating characteristic differences, behaviours and movement more effectively.
Developing the Approach: The Peregrine Falcon
Rather than concentrating on detailed rendering, the emphasis would be on capturing movement and identifying the characteristics that make the species visually recognisable. The animation drawing principles outlined by Williams (2001) and Hahn and Stanchfield (2023) would inform the gesture studies, while the biomechanical research of Wang et al. (2011) would provide insight into wing proportions and flight behaviour.
Species-specific information, including proportions, silhouette and behaviour, would be drawn from Ferguson-Lees and Christie (2005) and Aspinall and Porter (2020). The Cornell Lab of Ornithology's (2022) approach to quick sketching and recording visual information would also inform the process.
The intention was to experiment with whether information from scientific research could be translated into a simplified visual framework that would be useful to animators and visual artists.
Experimenting with Procreate
For this particular project, I wanted to take the opportunity to learn Procreate and experiment with drawing and painting on an iPad.
Throughout my professional career, Photoshop, Clip Studio Paint and Wacom tablets were the tools I had become accustomed to using. However, seeing how many of my students had adopted Procreate in recent years, along with the exceptional portability it offered, I realised it could be an ideal tool for drawing on location.
In the past, I had relied on traditional sketchbooks for drawing animals and environments outdoors. However, I was always a little frustrated with the mediums and materials I needed to carry, even if it was just a simple watercolour set.
After completing a few tutorials on the interface and functionality, I felt confident enough to try some location sketching and painting at Qudra Lakes. These are a series of man-made desert oases within the Al Marmoom Desert Conservation Reserve. One of the biggest highlights of the area is its biodiversity, with a wide variety of wildlife and bird species.
What remained was finding digital equivalents to my favourite Photoshop brushes and establishing a workflow that I was comfortable with. My first few sketches focused primarily on line art and capturing birds within their natural habitats.
Once I became comfortable with the drawing and sketching brushes, most of which I found within Procreate's Classic Brush sets, I moved on to experimenting with painting brushes.
This proved considerably more challenging. I wanted brushes that would allow me to capture flora and fauna quickly without investing too much time in rendering detail. This meant finding brushes with enough texture to compensate for the lack of detailed rendering.
I experimented with smudging techniques and textured brushes to speed up the process of covering as much of the canvas as possible without becoming overly concerned with detail.
After this period of experimentation, I wanted my final deliverables to look as though they had been created on toned paper. I experimented further with brushes and colour within Procreate before settling on the final brushes I would use for the mini project.
Although I doubted I would use colour extensively in the final work, I felt it was important to experiment with the overall aesthetic and consider how it might affect the presentation. These tests helped me determine which brushes provided the best balance between line art and tonal rendering. Comparing the results also helped establish potential workflows for future deliverables.
Experimenting with Gesture: Capturing the Peregrine Falcon
With the drawing workflow established, I began working on gesture studies, attempting to capture the movement and silhouette of the Peregrine Falcon using photographic and video references.
My focus was on the overall shape and movement of the bird rather than anatomical detail. I wanted to capture the flow of the body, wing positions and direction of movement.
However, using running-line gestures was not entirely successful. Although they captured movement and energy, I was clearly losing the specific characteristics that made a Peregrine Falcon identifiable. The drawings could easily have been mistaken for almost any other bird species. At best, we might have been able to identify the subject as a bird of prey based on its general movement and silhouette.
In trying to capture movement rapidly, specific proportions were repeatedly inaccurate.
I realised that without understanding which aspects of the Peregrine Falcon I needed to retain, the drawings were not successful in representing the species accurately, either as field studies or as artistic references.
Halfway through the initial loose gestures, I also realised that the principles of flowing lines through limbs and into extremities, as used when drawing many terrestrial animals, were proving challenging to apply to birds. Instead, I found myself relying on silhouettes to differentiate the wing masses in different poses.
Consequently, these drawings were no longer traditional running-line gestures. They had gradually evolved into more weighted drawings.
I began relying more heavily on contour gestures as I became familiar with the species. My natural inclination was to become more accurate when laying out each pose, particularly as I became increasingly frustrated with how much I had underestimated the difficulty of capturing birds through gesture compared to the terrestrial species I was accustomed to drawing.
I also experimented with adding white contour lines to help distinguish overlapping forms and clarify the structure of the bird.
Switching to Contour Gesture Drawing
I decided to explore contour gesture drawing to see whether it would improve my ability to remain faithful to the individual characteristics of the species while still capturing movement and structure.
Gesture drawing, by nature, needs to be rapid. While running-line gestures were generally faster, they were also more prone to misrepresenting the subject. Contour gesture drawing, on the other hand, significantly compromised speed.
In fact, trying to become more accurate in capturing individual characteristics demanded considerably more time.
I added some tonal work afterwards to polish the drawings. Even then, it quickly became apparent that without a thorough understanding of anatomy, not only Peregrine Falcon anatomy but bird anatomy in general, even the additional time I was spending was insufficient to accomplish what I had originally intended.
The task became even more difficult when considering variations within the species itself. Age, sex and geographic distribution can all contribute to differences in visual characteristics.
This exercise highlighted the need to spend considerably more time studying the skeletal and muscular systems of birds. I believe that developing this knowledge would allow me to make more informed decisions when drawing different poses, rather than relying solely on what is immediately visible in front of me, whether from a live specimen or photographic reference.
What I Discovered: The Limitations of Gesture Drawing
After working through the contour gesture studies, it became apparent that there were significant limitations to my original premise.
While gesture drawing allowed me to capture motion and general form, the more nuanced differences between species were almost entirely lost.
For example, among the approximately 40 species of falcon, many share similar proportions to the Peregrine Falcon. If colour information is removed, the similarities become even more apparent.
The mini project also demonstrated that slower and more carefully executed contour studies did not necessarily resolve the problem. Without a strong understanding of the precise anatomical and visual differences between species, additional drawing time alone was insufficient.
This was an important realisation. I had initially approached the project with the assumption that gesture drawing could provide a sufficiently reliable foundation for rapidly identifying and recording individual raptor species.
However, the experiments demonstrated that capturing movement and identifying a particular species are two very different challenges.
Conclusion: Towards a More Effective Visual Framework
It became obvious that before a quick-sketching framework could be developed, extensive study of general bird anatomy and species-specific anatomy would be required.
Gesture sketching, on its own, simply cannot form a reliable framework for representing individual bird species without substantial anatomical and species-specific study.
This does not mean that gesture drawing has no place in the process. Rather, it suggests that it needs to be supported by a stronger understanding of the subject and the visual characteristics that distinguish one species from another.
The original intention of this project was to develop a resource that would allow artists and animators to rapidly identify raptor species through simplified visual characteristics. Although the initial experiments did not produce the framework I had envisioned, they helped identify some of the challenges that need to be addressed before such a resource can be developed effectively.
Moving forward, I believe the next stage should involve a more systematic study of bird anatomy, particularly skeletal structure, wing proportions and the relationship between anatomy and flight mechanics. This could then be combined with species-specific visual comparisons, including silhouette, proportions, wing shape and characteristic flight patterns.
Ultimately, the goal remains to bridge the gap between ornithological identification and artistic observation, creating a resource that allows artists and animators to study, recognise and represent birds more effectively.
This initial exploration of the Peregrine Falcon is therefore a starting point rather than a finished framework. It has helped establish a clearer direction for the research and highlighted the importance of understanding what makes a species visually distinctive before attempting to capture it through gesture.
References
Aspinall, S., & Porter, R. (2020). Field guide to the birds of the United Arab Emirates. Helm.
Cornell Lab of Ornithology. (2022). Nature journaling and sketching tips for birders. All About Birds. https://www.allaboutbirds.org/news/nature-journaling-and-sketching-tips-for-birders/
Ferguson-Lees, J., & Christie, D. A. (2005). Raptors of the world: A field guide. https://www.scribd.com/document/293340252/Raptors-of-the-world
Hahn, D., & Stanchfield, W. (2023). Drawn to life: 20 golden years of Disney master classes. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003215356
Myers, G. E., & Arnheim, R. (1956). Art and visual perception: A psychology of the creative eye. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 16(3), 425. https://doi.org/10.2307/2104731
Wang, X., McGowan, A. J., & Dyke, G. J. (2011). Avian wing proportions and flight styles: First step towards predicting the flight modes of Mesozoic birds. PLOS ONE, 6(12), e28672. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028672
Williams, R. (2001). The animator's survival kit. Faber and Faber.






Comments
Post a Comment